Rusty Nickel Brewing Co.

Bourbon

• Black Button + Rusty Nickel Bespoke Blend for Rusty Nickel Brewing

  Bourbon · Rochester, NY

  Bourbon distilled at Black Button Distilling, and Hand Selected by Rusty Nickel Brewing. Exclusively sold at Rusty Nickel Brewing. Batches are released seasonally, and flavors will vary.

  1oz Shot $7.21

  1.5oz Pour $10.30

  2oz Pour $13.39

• Black Button Four Grain Bourbon

  Bourbon · 42.0% · Rochester, NY

  Black Button Four Grain Small-Batch Straight Bourbon is 60% Corn, 20% Wheat, 9% Rye, 11% Malted Barley and 100% NY state grown and distilled... more

  1oz Shot $6.70

  1.5oz Pour $9.79

  2oz Pour $12.88

Fruit Wines

• Midgard Alliance

  Fruit Wine · Corfu, NY

  5oz Glass $9.27

• Midgard Honey Apple

  Fruit Wine · Corfu, NY

  5oz Glass $11.33

Non-Alcoholic

• Athletic Run Wild

  Non-Alcoholic · 0.5% · Stratford, CT

  The ultimate session-able IPA. Brewed with a blend of Northwest hops with Citra and Mosaic at the forefront. Body of premium organic malts from US & Germany. Subtle yet complex malt profile.

  12oz Can $6.18

• Athletic Upside Dawn Golden Ale

  Non-Alcoholic · 0.5% · Stratford, CT

  Classic craft Golden Ale Style. Refreshing, clean, balanced, light-bodied. Aromas subtle with floral and earthy notes. Brewed with premium Vienna Malt along with combo of English and traditional American hops. Crafted to remove gluten*.

  12oz Can $6.18

Seasonal

• Rusty Nickel Apple Fritter Amber Ale

  Amber Ale · 4.9% · West Seneca, NY

  This American Amber Ale features a blend of rich maltiness, apple notes, and spices reminiscent of the warm, inviting flavors of freshly baked Apple Fritters.

  16oz Draft $7.21

Hard Seltzer

• Rusty Nickel Drift Hard Seltzer - It's Flippin' Grape

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · West Seneca, NY

  This refreshing hard seltzer is bursting with concord grape flavor!

  16oz Draft

• Rusty Nickel Drift Hard Seltzer Passionfruit Raspberry

  Hard Seltzer · 4.5% · West Seneca, NY

  Hard Seltzer Passionfruit Raspberry

  16oz Draft

Fruited Beers

• Rusty Nickel Slice O'Havens Orange-Vanilla Imperial Cream Ale

  Cream Ale · 9.8% · West Seneca, NY

  Indulge in heavenly layers of navel orange and vanilla, reminiscent of the famous ice cream novelty. An adult treat that’s smooth, creamy, and drinks real easy. Try it with a fresh zest of orange peel.

  10oz Draft $7.47

Sour & Tart

• Rusty Nickel Masked Defenders Caramelized Pineapple Sour

  Berliner Weisse · 4.5% · West Seneca, NY

  What happens when fresh ripe pineapple undergoes high heat treatment, caramelization - A delightful browning of sugar. Our caramelized pineapple sour is a crushable, refreshing, not too tart, not too sweet, fruited sour perfect for every occasion!

  16oz Can $7.73

• Rusty Nickel Passionfruit Peach Sour

  Alpine Style Pils · 4.9% · West Seneca, NY

  16oz Draft

Light & Crisp

• Eli Fish Norm!

  Kolsch · 4.7% · Batavia

  Kolsch style Ale brewed with local malt and noble German hops.

  16oz Draft

Malty & Sweet

• Rusty Nickel Irish Red

  Irish Red Ale · 5.7% · West Seneca, NY

  An amber-hued beauty that goes great with any meal. Well balanced, light on the palate, hints of caramel and a nod to the lightly kilned malts. Look for a subtle hint of cherry on the finish.

  16oz Draft $6.70

• Rusty Nickel Sprocktoberfest

  Oktoberfest · 5.2% · West Seneca, NY

  A German Marzen lagered for months. The long, cold storage yields an incredibly smooth and mellow beer. The malts impart a light sweetness with rich, bread, toasty flavors. A beer brewed to style, that needs no change.

  16oz Draft $7.21

Dark & Roasty

• Rusty Nickel Chocolate Milk Money Nitro

  Milk Stout · 5.5% · West Seneca, NY

  How does a brew become a flagship? Customer love! And there is tons of love for our Chocolate Milk Money Milk Stout. Full-bodied and silky smooth, with rich bold notes of creamy milk and chocolate. Well-balanced with low bitterness, and a noticeable sweet

  16oz Draft $7.47

• Rusty Nickel Ms. Brown's Porter

  Porter · 4.5% · West Seneca, NY

  English Brown Porter with notes of roasted toffee.

  16oz Draft $6.95

• Rusty Nickel Vanilla Chai Tea

  Milk Stout · 5.2% · West Seneca, NY

  This beer is a culinary bonanza of black tea, chai spices, cinnamon, and vanilla. Perfect for any time of the day, you’ll be eager to tell your friends about this brew

  16oz Draft $7.47

Hop Forward

• Rusty Nickel Dolcita Krush Hazy Ipa

  Hazy IPA · 5.5% · West Seneca, NY

  Hazy, crisp, and bright. A nose of peach berries...if you can imagine! With a smooth, easy finish.

  16oz Draft $7.21

• Rusty Nickel I Remember, Buffalo

  American Pale Ale · 6.8% · West Seneca, NY

  Bright, hoppy, full of character, with a crisp malt backbone. Medium-bodied with a smooth bitterness, it finishes clean and refreshing.

  16oz Draft $7.47

• Rusty Nickel Kickin' Back Session Ipa

  Session IPA · 4.6% · West Seneca, NY

  Mouthy feel with slight bitterness.

  16oz Draft $6.95

• Rusty Nickel Tropical Vapor Rocket

  NE/Hazy IPA · 6.8% · West Seneca, NY

  This soft and hazy IPA is taking off with hop flavor and aroma. Dry-hopped with citra and Galaxy you'll find a universe of flavors such as citrus, passionfruit, mango, strawberry, and stone fruit.

  16oz Draft $7.73

• WNYBG Collab Be Good, Do Good, Brew Beer

  Hazy IPA · 7.0% · Buffalo, NY

  Brewed for WNY Craft Beer Week 2025. This hazy 7% NEIPA is a true community creation, brewed in collaboration with members of the Western New York Brewers Guild. Bursting with juicy waves of tropical fruit, citrus, and a touch of stone fruit, it’s soft on the palate with a pillowy mouthfeel... more

  16oz Draft $7.50

Hard Cider

• BlackBird Estate Reserve

  Dry Cider · 6.5% · Barker, NY

  A semi-dry hard apple cider with an apple aroma and crisp refreshing finish.

  12oz Can $7.21

• BlackBird Premium Draft

  Semi-Sweet Cider · 6.5% · Barker, NY

  12oz Can $7.21

Mead

• Lilly Belle Black Magic Mead

  Mead · 4.0% · Lancaster, NY

  Spiced mead with sassafras, licorice & vanilla. Notes of earthy root beer.

  16oz Draft $9.27

• Lilly Belle Mead Crystal Blue Meth

  Mead · 6.0% · Lancaster, NY

  Blueberry, raspberry and rosemary flavors.

  16oz Draft $9.27

Canned Cocktails

• CanBee Bee’s Knees

  Cocktail · 8.0% · Rochester, New York

  Gin, Lemon, Honey, and seltzer water

  12oz Can $8.24

Liqueur

• Black Button Empire Apple Liqueur

  Liqueur · Rochester, NY

  1oz Shot $5.67

  1.5oz Pour $8.76

  2oz Pour $11.85

• Niagara Craft Spirits 1808 Krupnik

  Liqueur · Lockport, NY

  1oz Shot $4.64

  1.5oz Pour $7.73

  2oz Pour $10.82

Tequila

• Steelbound Blanco Tequila

  Tequila · Buffalo, NY

  1oz Shot $4.64

  1.5oz Pour $7.73

  2oz Pour $10.30

• Steelbound Reposado Tequila

  Tequila · Buffalo, NY

  1oz Shot $5.67

  1.5oz Pour $8.76

  2oz Pour $11.85

Gin

• Black Button American Dry Gin

  Gin · Rochester, NY

  1oz Shot $5.15

  1.5oz Pour $8.24

  2oz Pour $11.33

• Cooperstown Saratoga Fenimore Gin

  Gin · Cooperstown, NY

  1oz Shot $4.12

  1.5oz Pour $7.21

  2oz Pour $9.27

Vodka

• Albany Orange Vodka

  Flavored Vodka

  1oz Shot $4.12

  1.5oz Pour $7.21

  2oz Pour $9.27

• Black Button American Corn Vodka

  Vodka · 40.0% · Rochester, NY

  Sourced from quality New York State corn, Black Button Distilling’s All American Corn Vodka has a smoother taste than other corn vodkas. Sweeter, more character-forward, and certified gluten free, this is a vodka that everyone will love.

  1oz Shot $4.12

  1.5oz Pour $7.21

  2oz Pour $9.27

Whisk(e)y

• Black Button American Straight Whiskey

  Whisk(e)y · 45.0% · Rochester, NY

  Whether you enjoy it neat, in a cocktail or on the rocks, we present to you our Black Button American Straight Whiskey: For as long as Farms have existed, "Cooperatives" have been a way for a group of family businesses to pool their resources together to create a better product... more

  1oz Shot $5.15

  1.5oz Pour $8.24

  2oz Pour $11.33

• Black Button Empire Straight Rye Whiskey

  Rye Whiskey · 42.0% · Rochester, NY

  Black pepper bite that is balanced with the subtle taste of stone fruit. It finishes with a nutty, woody taste imparted from the hand charred American White Oak barrels it has aged in for the last few years. 94% Rye, 6% Malted Barley and 100% NY made from grain to glass.

  1oz Shot $8.24

  1.5oz Pour $11.33

  2oz Pour $14.42

On Tap

• Rusty Nickel Cafe Mocha Latte

  Milk Stout · 5.5% · West Seneca, NY

  Chocolate. Coffee. Creamy and smoooooth. Made with a custom coffee blend from steam works coffee company and the sitting room buffalo.

  16oz Draft

• Rusty Nickel Drift BlackBerry Lime

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · West Seneca, NY

  Real blackberry and lime purées provide a balance of light aroma and flavors. Incredibly refreshing!

  16oz Draft

• Rusty Nickel Fuzzy Navel

  Wheat Ale · 4.5% · West Seneca, NY

  American Wheat Beer brewed with White Peach and Navel Orange

  16oz Draft

Bottles

• 21 Brix Ella's Red

  Red Blend · 13.0% · Portland, NY

  Sweet

  Glass $11.33

• 21 Brix Pinot Grigio

  Pinot Grigio · 12.2% · Portland, NY

  This light-bodied dry white wine possesses a delicate floral bouquet and fresh fruity flavors that linger on the palate. This Pinot Grigio pairs well with appetizers. Serve well-chilled.

  Glass $9.27

• 21 Brix Thirsty Elephant

  Red Blend · 12.0% · Portland, NY

  Sweet

  Glass $12.36

• Black Button + Rusty Nickel Bespoke Blend for Rusty Nickel Brewing

  Bourbon · Rochester, NY

  Bourbon distilled at Black Button Distilling, and Hand Selected by Rusty Nickel Brewing. Exclusively sold at Rusty Nickel Brewing. Batches are released seasonally, and flavors will vary.

  Pour

• Black Button American Corn Vodka

  Vodka · 40.0% · Rochester, NY

  Sourced from quality New York State corn, Black Button Distilling’s All American Corn Vodka has a smoother taste than other corn vodkas. Sweeter, more character-forward, and certified gluten free, this is a vodka that everyone will love.

  Pour

• Black Button Bespoke Bourbon Cream

  Liqueur · 15.0% · Rochester, NY

  At Black Button Distilling, we believe that Bourbon is an even better match for cream than Irish Whiskey and we encourage you to see for yourself... more

  Pour

• Black Button Empire Straight Rye Whiskey

  Rye Whiskey · 42.0% · Rochester, NY

  Black pepper bite that is balanced with the subtle taste of stone fruit. It finishes with a nutty, woody taste imparted from the hand charred American White Oak barrels it has aged in for the last few years. 94% Rye, 6% Malted Barley and 100% NY made from grain to glass.

  Pour

• Black Button Four Grain Bourbon

  Bourbon · 42.0% · Rochester, NY

  Black Button Four Grain Small-Batch Straight Bourbon is 60% Corn, 20% Wheat, 9% Rye, 11% Malted Barley and 100% NY state grown and distilled... more

  Pour

White Wine

• 21 Brix Ella's White

  White Wine · 12.0% · Portland, NY

  Made entirely of Niagara grapes, Ella’s White is a sweet white wine that embodies everything you love about white grapes. True to the fruit with a hint of pear flavor, very aromatic, with a smooth lingering finish make it hard to put down.

  5oz Glass $10.30

  1.5L Carafe $37.08

• 21 Brix Naked Chardonnay

  Chardonnay · 12.5% · Portland, NY

  Un-oaked Chardonnay

  5oz Glass $9.27

  750ml Carafe $32.96

• 21 Brix Pinot Grigio

  Pinot Grigio · 12.2% · Portland, NY

  This light-bodied dry white wine possesses a delicate floral bouquet and fresh fruity flavors that linger on the palate. This Pinot Grigio pairs well with appetizers. Serve well-chilled.

  5oz Glass $9.27

  750ml Bottle $32.96

• 21 Brix Semi Dry Riesling

  Riesling · Portland, NY

  5oz Glass $10.30

  750ml Carafe $37.08

• Ryan William Riesling

  Riesling · Burdett, NY

  5oz Glass $8.24

  750ml Carafe $28.84

Rosé Wine

• Glenora Dry Rosé

  Rosé · Dundee, NY

  5oz Glass $10.30

  750ml Carafe $37.08

Red Wine

• 21 Brix Cabernet Sauvignon

  Cabernet Sauvignon · 13.0% · Portland, NY

  Dry

  5oz Glass $12.36

  750ml Carafe $45.32

• 21 Brix Ella's Red

  Red Blend · 13.0% · Portland, NY

  Sweet

  5oz Glass $10.30

  1.5L Carafe $37.08

• 21 Brix Pinot Noir

  Pinot Noir · 12.0% · Portland, NY

  Dry Red

  5oz Glass $12.36

  750ml Carafe $45.32

• Goose Watch Renaissance Red

  Red Wine · 11.5% · Romulus, NY

  This lighter styled unoaked semi-dry red wine exhibits luscious berry fruit aromas and a lively finish. Serve chilled or at cool room temperature at summer picnics, or with pizza, pasta, and burgers.

  5oz Glass $7.21

Update this Beer Menu