Rusty Nickel Brewing Co.

Bourbon

• Black Button + Rusty Nickel Bespoke Blend for Rusty Nickel Brewing

  Bourbon · Rochester, NY

  Bourbon distilled at Black Button Distilling, and Hand Selected by Rusty Nickel Brewing. Exclusively sold at Rusty Nickel Brewing. Batches are released seasonally, and flavors will vary.

  1oz Shot $7.21

  1.5oz Pour $10.30

  2oz Pour $13.39

• Black Button Four Grain Bourbon

  Bourbon · 42.0% · Rochester, NY

  Black Button Four Grain Small-Batch Straight Bourbon is 60% Corn, 20% Wheat, 9% Rye, 11% Malted Barley and 100% NY state grown and distilled... more

  1oz Shot $6.70

  1.5oz Pour $9.79

  2oz Pour $12.88

Fruit Wines

• Midgard Alliance

  Fruit Wine · Corfu, NY

  5oz Glass $9.27

• Midgard Honey Apple

  Fruit Wine · Corfu, NY

  5oz Glass $11.33

Non-Alcoholic

• Athletic Run Wild

  Non-Alcoholic · 0.5% · Stratford, CT

  The ultimate session-able IPA. Brewed with a blend of Northwest hops with Citra and Mosaic at the forefront. Body of premium organic malts from US & Germany. Subtle yet complex malt profile.

  12oz Can $6.18

• Athletic Upside Dawn Golden Ale

  Non-Alcoholic · 0.5% · Stratford, CT

  Classic craft Golden Ale Style. Refreshing, clean, balanced, light-bodied. Aromas subtle with floral and earthy notes. Brewed with premium Vienna Malt along with combo of English and traditional American hops. Crafted to remove gluten*.

  12oz Can $6.18

Seasonal

• Rusty Nickel Apple Fritter Amber Ale

  Amber Ale · 4.9% · West Seneca, NY

  This American Amber Ale features a blend of rich maltiness, apple notes, and spices reminiscent of the warm, inviting flavors of freshly baked Apple Fritters.

  16oz Draft $7.21

• Rusty Nickel Garden Of Eden Pumpkin Ale

  Spiced Beer · 6.1% · West Seneca, NY

  Our oldest recipe calls for fresh-picked, locally-grown pie pumpkins. These pumpkins are grown specifically for Rusty Nickel Brewing by Zittle's Farm in Eden, NY. Harvested at the peak of ripeness, we transform them into a deliciously sweet and spicy ale!

  16oz Draft $6.95

Hard Seltzer

• Rusty Nickel Drift BlackBerry Lime

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · West Seneca, NY

  Real blackberry and lime purées provide a balance of light aroma and flavors. Incredibly refreshing!

  16oz Draft $6.95

• Rusty Nickel Drift Hard Seltzer - It's Flippin' Grape

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · West Seneca, NY

  This refreshing hard seltzer is bursting with concord grape flavor!

  16oz Draft $6.95

• Rusty Nickel Drift Hard Seltzer - Cosmo

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · West Seneca, NY

  Inspired by the infamous Cosmopolitan cocktail, this hard seltzer is not too sweet and not too tart with bright fruit notes.

  16oz Draft $6.95

Sour & Tart

• Rusty Nickel Masked Defenders Triple Berry Sour

  Berliner Weisse · 4.5% · West Seneca, NY

  Ultra juicy, refreshing and 100% real fruit! Made with Blueberry, Raspberry, and Strawberry. One sip and you're waiting for the bartender to pour another!

  16oz Draft

Light & Crisp

• Rusty Nickel Czech Pils

  Bohemian Pilsner · 5.1% · West Seneca, NY

  Combining Czech Bohemian Pilsner malt and Czech Saaz hops provides a crisp flavor, showcasing a subtle but present noble hop aroma and taste.

  16oz Draft $6.95

• Rusty Nickel To The Box

  Bavarian Lager · 5.0% · West Seneca, NY

  B-O-X! B-O-X! To the Box! To the Box! To the Box, Box, Box! Woooo! To the Box Lager is a smooth, crisp beer, inspired by the fast-paced action of lacrosse, celebrating the spirit and camaraderie of Buffalo's lacrosse community. Simple, Crisp, Crushable!

  Draft

• Rusty Nickel True Pils Fan!

  Pilsner · 4.1% · West Seneca, NY

  From tailgate to post-game this light German Pilsner is crisp, clean, and refreshing! A perfect easy drinker for your game day traditions!

  16oz Draft $6.95

Malty & Sweet

• Rusty Nickel Irish Red

  Irish Red Ale · 5.7% · West Seneca, NY

  An amber-hued beauty that goes great with any meal. Well balanced, light on the palate, hints of caramel and a nod to the lightly kilned malts. Look for a subtle hint of cherry on the finish.

  16oz Draft $6.70

• Rusty Nickel Sprocktoberfest

  Oktoberfest · 5.2% · West Seneca, NY

  A German Marzen lagered for months. The long, cold storage yields an incredibly smooth and mellow beer. The malts impart a light sweetness with rich, bread, toasty flavors. A beer brewed to style, that needs no change.

  16oz Draft $7.21

Dark & Roasty

• Rusty Nickel Cafe Mocha Latte Nitro

  Nitro Stout · 4.5% · West Seneca, NY

  Coffee. Chocolate. Milk. The name says it all. We blend our custom roasted French-pressed cold-brewed coffee with our delightful chocolate milk stout for an out of this world Cafe Mocha Latte experience.

  16oz Draft $7.21

• Rusty Nickel Chocolate Milk Money Nitro

  Milk Stout · 5.5% · West Seneca, NY

  How does a brew become a flagship? Customer love! And there is tons of love for our Chocolate Milk Money Milk Stout. Full-bodied and silky smooth, with rich bold notes of creamy milk and chocolate. Well-balanced with low bitterness, and a noticeable sweet

  16oz Draft $7.47

• Rusty Nickel Ms. Brown's Porter

  Porter · 4.5% · West Seneca, NY

  English Brown Porter with notes of roasted toffee.

  16oz Draft $6.95

• Rusty Nickel Vanilla Chai Tea

  Milk Stout · 5.2% · West Seneca, NY

  This beer is a culinary bonanza of black tea, chai spices, cinnamon, and vanilla. Perfect for any time of the day, you’ll be eager to tell your friends about this brew

  16oz Draft $7.47

Hop Forward

• Rusty Nickel Buffalo What?

  IPA · 6.3% · West Seneca, NY

  A bold and hoppy IPA brewed for those who enjoy a crisp, full-bodied IPA with a punch of citrus and pine. Brewed to match the heart, hustle, and grit of Buffalo's unstoppable lacrosse team, and to be enjoyed by the best fan-base in the league.

  16oz Draft

• Rusty Nickel Dolcita Krush Hazy Ipa

  Hazy IPA · 5.5% · West Seneca, NY

  Hazy, crisp, and bright. A nose of peach berries...if you can imagine! With a smooth, easy finish.

  16oz Draft $7.21

• Rusty Nickel I Remember, Buffalo

  American Pale Ale · 6.8% · West Seneca, NY

  Bright, hoppy, full of character, with a crisp malt backbone. Medium-bodied with a smooth bitterness, it finishes clean and refreshing.

  16oz Draft $7.47

Hard Cider

• BlackBird Estate Reserve

  Dry Cider · 6.5% · Barker, NY

  A semi-dry hard apple cider with an apple aroma and crisp refreshing finish.

  12oz Can $7.21

• BlackBird Premium Draft

  Semi-Sweet Cider · 6.5% · Barker, NY

  12oz Can $7.21

Mead

• Lilly Belle Black Magic Mead

  Mead · 4.0% · Lancaster, NY

  Spiced mead with sassafras, licorice & vanilla. Notes of earthy root beer.

  16oz Draft $9.27

• Lilly Belle Mead Crystal Blue Meth

  Mead · 6.0% · Lancaster, NY

  Blueberry, raspberry and rosemary flavors.

  16oz Draft $9.27

Canned Cocktails

• CanBee Bee’s Knees

  Cocktail · 8.0% · Rochester, New York

  Gin, Lemon, Honey, and seltzer water

  12oz Can $8.24

Liqueur

• Black Button Empire Apple Liqueur

  Liqueur · 23.0% · Rochester, NY

  Our Apple Liqueur’s swirls of cinnamon and mouthwatering locally grown New York State apples are enriched by our bourbon’s signature notes of caramel and vanilla. Our Master Distillers have handcrafted a tasting experience unlike any other... more

  1oz Shot $5.67

  1.5oz Pour $8.76

  2oz Pour $11.85

• Niagara Craft Spirits 1808 Krupnik

  Liqueur · 38.0% · Lockport, NY

  1808 Krupnik is distilled from local Niagara County wine. 100% of the alcohol is distilled, by us, at our distillery, from local wine... more

  1oz Shot $4.64

  1.5oz Pour $7.73

  2oz Pour $10.82

Tequila

• Steelbound Blanco Tequila

  Tequila · 40.0% · Buffalo, NY

  Introducing Blanco, a premium tequila that seamlessly blends tradition with innovation. Crafted with 100% Blue Agave imported from the rich soils of Mexico, and combined with the finest NY corn, this tequila is a testament to masterful distillation... more

  1oz Shot $4.64

  1.5oz Pour $7.73

  2oz Pour $10.30

• Steelbound Reposado Tequila

  Tequila · 40.0% · Buffalo, NY

  Smooth and mellow with a medium-bodied texture. Sweet flavors of corn and caramel dominate the palate. Rich notes of vanilla and butterscotch.

  1oz Shot $5.67

  1.5oz Pour $8.76

  2oz Pour $11.85

Gin

• Black Button American Dry Gin

  Gin · 42.0% · Rochester, NY

  American Dry Gins are made to explore a more complex aromatic element using traditional botanicals that complement and balance each other... more

  1oz Shot $5.15

  1.5oz Pour $8.24

  2oz Pour $11.33

• Cooperstown Saratoga Fenimore Gin

  Gin · 40.0% · Cooperstown, NY

  Our Saratoga Fenimore Gin is a lovingly handcrafted hot vapor extraction recipe of thirteen botanicals... more

  1oz Shot $4.12

  1.5oz Pour $7.21

  2oz Pour $9.27

Vodka

• Albany Orange Vodka

  Flavored Vodka · 40.0% · Albany, NY

  Made from 100% American corn: crisp, clean, and gluten-free. Obsessively filtered and bottled by the Albany Distilling Company. Smooth with a polished finish.

  1oz Shot $4.12

  1.5oz Pour $7.21

  2oz Pour $9.27

• Black Button American Corn Vodka

  Vodka · 40.0% · Rochester, NY

  Sourced from quality New York State corn, Black Button Distilling’s All American Corn Vodka has a smoother taste than other corn vodkas. Sweeter, more character-forward, and certified gluten free, this is a vodka that everyone will love.

  1oz Shot $4.12

  1.5oz Pour $7.21

  2oz Pour $9.27

Whisk(e)y

• Black Button American Straight Whiskey

  Whisk(e)y · 45.0% · Rochester, NY

  Whether you enjoy it neat, in a cocktail or on the rocks, we present to you our Black Button American Straight Whiskey: For as long as Farms have existed, "Cooperatives" have been a way for a group of family businesses to pool their resources together to create a better product... more

  1oz Shot $5.15

  1.5oz Pour $8.24

  2oz Pour $11.33

• Black Button Empire Straight Rye Whiskey

  Rye Whiskey · 42.0% · Rochester, NY

  Black pepper bite that is balanced with the subtle taste of stone fruit. It finishes with a nutty, woody taste imparted from the hand charred American White Oak barrels it has aged in for the last few years. 94% Rye, 6% Malted Barley and 100% NY made from grain to glass.

  1oz Shot $8.24

  1.5oz Pour $11.33

  2oz Pour $14.42

On Tap

• Rusty Nickel Cafe Mocha Latte

  Milk Stout · 5.5% · West Seneca, NY

  Chocolate. Coffee. Creamy and smoooooth. Made with a custom coffee blend from steam works coffee company and the sitting room buffalo.

  16oz Draft

• Rusty Nickel Drift BlackBerry Lime

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · West Seneca, NY

  Real blackberry and lime purées provide a balance of light aroma and flavors. Incredibly refreshing!

  16oz Draft

• Rusty Nickel Fuzzy Navel

  Wheat Ale · 4.5% · West Seneca, NY

  American Wheat Beer brewed with White Peach and Navel Orange

  16oz Draft

Bottles

• 21 Brix Ella's Red

  Red Blend · 13.0% · Portland, NY

  Sweet

  Glass $11.33

• 21 Brix Pinot Grigio

  Pinot Grigio · 12.2% · Portland, NY

  This light-bodied dry white wine possesses a delicate floral bouquet and fresh fruity flavors that linger on the palate. This Pinot Grigio pairs well with appetizers. Serve well-chilled.

  Glass $9.27

• 21 Brix Thirsty Elephant

  Red Blend · 12.0% · Portland, NY

  Sweet

  Glass $12.36

• Black Button + Rusty Nickel Bespoke Blend for Rusty Nickel Brewing

  Bourbon · Rochester, NY

  Bourbon distilled at Black Button Distilling, and Hand Selected by Rusty Nickel Brewing. Exclusively sold at Rusty Nickel Brewing. Batches are released seasonally, and flavors will vary.

  Pour

• Black Button American Corn Vodka

  Vodka · 40.0% · Rochester, NY

  Sourced from quality New York State corn, Black Button Distilling’s All American Corn Vodka has a smoother taste than other corn vodkas. Sweeter, more character-forward, and certified gluten free, this is a vodka that everyone will love.

  Pour

• Black Button Bespoke Bourbon Cream

  Liqueur · 15.0% · Rochester, NY

  At Black Button Distilling, we believe that Bourbon is an even better match for cream than Irish Whiskey and we encourage you to see for yourself... more

  Pour

• Black Button Empire Straight Rye Whiskey

  Rye Whiskey · 42.0% · Rochester, NY

  Black pepper bite that is balanced with the subtle taste of stone fruit. It finishes with a nutty, woody taste imparted from the hand charred American White Oak barrels it has aged in for the last few years. 94% Rye, 6% Malted Barley and 100% NY made from grain to glass.

  Pour

• Black Button Four Grain Bourbon

  Bourbon · 42.0% · Rochester, NY

  Black Button Four Grain Small-Batch Straight Bourbon is 60% Corn, 20% Wheat, 9% Rye, 11% Malted Barley and 100% NY state grown and distilled... more

  Pour

White Wine

• 21 Brix Ella's White

  White Wine · 12.0% · Portland, NY

  Made entirely of Niagara grapes, Ella’s White is a sweet white wine that embodies everything you love about white grapes. True to the fruit with a hint of pear flavor, very aromatic, with a smooth lingering finish make it hard to put down.

  5oz Glass $10.30

  1.5L Carafe $37.08

• 21 Brix Naked Chardonnay

  Chardonnay · 12.5% · Portland, NY

  Un-oaked Chardonnay

  5oz Glass $9.27

  750ml Carafe $32.96

• 21 Brix Pinot Grigio

  Pinot Grigio · 12.2% · Portland, NY

  This light-bodied dry white wine possesses a delicate floral bouquet and fresh fruity flavors that linger on the palate. This Pinot Grigio pairs well with appetizers. Serve well-chilled.

  5oz Glass $9.27

  750ml Bottle $32.96

• Ryan William Riesling

  Riesling · Burdett, NY

  5oz Glass $8.24

  750ml Carafe $28.84

Rosé Wine

• Glenora Dry Rosé

  Rosé · Dundee, NY

  5oz Glass $10.30

  750ml Carafe $37.08

Red Wine

• 21 Brix Cabernet Sauvignon

  Cabernet Sauvignon · 13.0% · Portland, NY

  Dry

  5oz Glass $12.36

  750ml Carafe $45.32

• 21 Brix Ella's Red

  Red Blend · 13.0% · Portland, NY

  Sweet

  5oz Glass $10.30

  1.5L Carafe $37.08

• 21 Brix Pinot Noir

  Pinot Noir · 12.0% · Portland, NY

  Dry Red

  5oz Glass $12.36

  750ml Carafe $45.32

• Goose Watch Renaissance Red

  Red Wine · 11.5% · Romulus, NY

  This lighter styled unoaked semi-dry red wine exhibits luscious berry fruit aromas and a lively finish. Serve chilled or at cool room temperature at summer picnics, or with pizza, pasta, and burgers.

  5oz Glass $7.21

Update this Beer Menu